Plans and programmes include orders and circulars setting conditions for wind turbines, requiring environmental assessment.

European Court of Justice (Grand Chamber) · 25 juni 2020 · Judgment · Preliminary ruling

(Reference for a preliminary ruling — Directive 2001/42/EC — Environmental impact assessment — Development consent for the installation of wind turbines — Article 2(a) — Concept of ‘plans and programmes’ — Conditions for granting consent laid down by an order and a circular — Article 3(2)(a) — National instruments setting the framework for future development consent of projects — Absence of environmental assessment — Maintenance of the effects of national instruments, and consents granted on the basis of those instruments, after those instruments have been declared not to comply with EU law — Conditions)

Rechtsvraag

Whether Article 2(a) and Article 3(2)(a) of Directive 2001/42/EC require an environmental assessment for the Flemish Order and Circular concerning the installation and operation of wind turbines, and if not complied with, whether the effects of these instruments and any consents granted under them can be maintained.

Regel

  • Article 2(a), Directive 2001/42/EC (defines 'plans and programmes' subject to preparation/adoption by an authority and required by legislative/regulatory/administrative provisions)
  • Article 3(2)(a), Directive 2001/42/EC (requires environmental assessments for plans and programmes prepared for specific sectors and setting the framework for future development consent of projects listed in Annexes I and II to Directive 2011/92/EU)
  • Principle of Sincere Cooperation, Article 4(3) TEU (requires Member States to eliminate unlawful consequences of a breach of EU law)
  • Case Law: Inter-Environnement Bruxelles (C-567/10), Thybaut and Others (C-160/17), D’Oultremont and Others (C-290/15), Association France Nature Environnement (C-379/15), and Inter-Environnement Wallonie and Bond Beter Leefmilieu Vlaanderen (C-411/17)

Conclusie

The Order and Circular of 2006 qualify as 'plans and programmes' under Article 2(a) of Directive 2001/42/EC and must be subject to an environmental assessment as per Article 3(2)(a). If such an assessment was not conducted, the national court may maintain their effects only if permitted by national law and necessary to avoid significant disruptions to electricity supply, and only for the period strictly necessary to remedy the breach.

Tijdlijn

  1. 26-02-1991 The Convention on Environmental Impact Assessment in a Transboundary Context was signed in Espoo, Finland.
  2. 24-06-1997 The Espoo Convention was approved on behalf of the European Community.
  3. 10-09-1997 The Espoo Convention entered into force.
  4. 01-06-1995 The Order of the Flemish Government on the general and sectoral provisions with regard to environmental health (Vlarem II) was adopted.
  5. 12-05-2006 The Circular EME/2006/01-RO/2006/02, entitled 'Assessment framework and conditions for the installation of wind turbines,' was adopted.
  6. 23-12-2011 Article 99 of the Order of the Flemish Government amending the Vlarem II was introduced, adding Section 5.20.6 regarding installations for the generation of electricity by means of wind turbines.
  7. 30-11-2016 Development consent for the installation and operation of five wind turbines on the territory of the communes of Aalter and Nevele was granted to Electrobel SA.
  8. 04-12-2018 The Raad voor Vergunningsbetwistingen decided to refer questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union for a preliminary ruling.
  9. 15-01-2019 The Court of Justice of the European Union received the preliminary ruling request from the Raad voor Vergunningsbetwistingen.
  10. 09-12-2019 A hearing was held at the Court of Justice of the European Union regarding the case.
  11. 03-03-2020 The Advocate General delivered an opinion on the case.
  12. 25-06-2020 The Court of Justice of the European Union delivered its judgment in Case C-24/19.