Board of Appeal can consider late evidence of genuine use if relevant and procedurally appropriate.
(Appeal — EU trade mark — Regulation (EC) No 207/2009 — Article 15(1) — Article 57(2) and (3) — Article 64 — Article 76(2) — Regulation (EC) No 2868/95 — Rule 22(2) — Rule 40(6) — Invalidity proceedings — Applications for a declaration of invalidity based on an earlier national trade mark — Genuine use of the earlier mark — Burden of proof — Rejection of the applications — Taking into account by the Board of Appeal of the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) of new evidence — Annulment of the decisions of the Cancellation Division of EUIPO — Referral — Consequences)
Rechtsvraag
Whether the Board of Appeal of the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) was entitled to take into account evidence of genuine use of an earlier national trade mark produced for the first time before it, and whether it was correct in annulling the decisions of the Cancellation Division and remitting the case for further examination.
Regel
- Article 15(1), Regulation (EC) No 207/2009 (EU Trade Mark) (An EU trade mark must be put to genuine use within five years following registration or it is subject to sanctions)
- Article 57(2) and (3), Regulation (EC) No 207/2009 (Burden of proof for genuine use of an earlier trade mark lies with the proprietor of that mark during invalidity proceedings)
- Article 64, Regulation (EC) No 207/2009 (Board of Appeal's powers to decide on the appeal or remit the case for further prosecution)
- Article 76(2), Regulation (EC) No 207/2009 (EUIPO's discretion to disregard facts or evidence not submitted in due time)
- Rule 22(2), Commission Regulation (EC) No 2868/95 (Proof of use must be provided within a specified period or the opposition shall be rejected)
- Rule 40(6), Commission Regulation (EC) No 2868/95 (Proof of use must be provided within a specified period in invalidity proceedings or the application shall be rejected)
Conclusie
The court dismissed the appeal, upholding the Board of Appeal's decision to consider additional evidence of genuine use submitted by Rezon and to remit the case to the Cancellation Division for further examination. The court found that the Board of Appeal acted within its discretion under Article 76(2) of Regulation No 207/2009 and that the additional evidence was relevant and justified taking into account.
Tijdlijn
- 17-11-2008 mobile.de GmbH filed two applications for EU trade marks with EUIPO concerning the word mark ‘mobile.de’ and a specific figurative sign.
- 26-01-2010 The word mark ‘mobile.de’ was registered by EUIPO.
- 29-09-2010 The figurative mark associated with ‘mobile.de’ was registered by EUIPO.
- 18-01-2011 Rezon OOD filed two applications for a declaration of invalidity for the word mark and figurative mark ‘mobile.de’ with EUIPO.
- 28-03-2013 The Cancellation Division of EUIPO rejected the applications for a declaration of invalidity filed by Rezon OOD on the ground that Rezon had not provided proof of genuine use of the earlier national mark.
- 09-01-2014 The Board of Appeal of EUIPO annulled the Cancellation Division decisions, taking into account additional evidence provided by Rezon OOD and found genuine use of the earlier national mark for advertising services for motor vehicles.
- 13-02-2014 The Board of Appeal referred the cases back to the Cancellation Division for further examination of the applications for a declaration of invalidity.
- 06-05-2014 mobile.de GmbH filed an action for annulment of the Board of Appeal’s decision with the General Court (Case T-325/14).
- 07-05-2014 mobile.de GmbH filed another action for annulment of the Board of Appeal’s decision with the General Court (Case T-322/14).
- 04-03-2016 The General Court ordered the joinder of Cases T-322/14 and T-325/14 for the purposes of the decision closing the proceedings.
- 12-05-2016 The General Court dismissed the annulment actions filed by mobile.de GmbH.
- 27-07-2016 mobile.de GmbH filed an appeal under Article 56 of the Statute of the Court of Justice of the European Union.